Hands-on

·

8 min read

The value of design is in everyone else’s budget.

Engineers read cost, product and design read value, and both are right on their own lines. One page per decision turns the argument into a trade. With cases from hardware and software.

Terraced fields seen from above, each terrace a narrow line following the slope

In short

Design is booked as a cost, while its value lands in price, unit cost, tooling, logistics, time, service and the next product. Put one decision and every line it touches on a single page, and the argument between cost and value becomes a trade.

01 The bill

Cost thinking and value thinking read different lines of the same product.

02 The trade

A saving on one line pays for value on another. A pallet can pay for a light.

03 The evidence

Cause is shown for single decisions. The broad claims rest on correlation.

Design looks like a cost because that is how it is booked. Its value lands elsewhere: in price and volume, unit cost, tooling, logistics, time to market, warranty and service, and in the next product built on the same parts. Those lines belong to different people, which is why the same decision can look wasteful in one meeting and obvious in the next. The way out is modest. Take one design decision, put every line it touches on one page, and decide on the sum.

Two ways to read the same product

Most hardware teams know the argument. Engineers, project leads and purchasing think in cost: parts, tooling, assembly time. Product management, sales, strategy and design think in value: what a buyer notices, what the product can charge, what it says about the company. Both are doing their job. Each reads the lines it is responsible for (Exhibit 1).

Exhibit 1

Design is booked on one line. Its value lands on seven others.

On the left, how a design decision appears in the accounts, and what design decides. On the right, the seven lines where its effect shows up: the design levers that move each one, how it is measured and who owns the number.

Where a design decision is booked, and where it shows up

What it means. The people who see the cost and the people who see the value read different lines. Put all of them on one page before the meeting, and the discussion is about the sum.

Sources and method

My own model. It extends the four classic trade-offs of product development economics (development expense, unit cost, product performance and time to market), as in Smith and Reinertsen, Developing Products in Half the Time (1991). Tooling cost drivers such as undercuts, side actions and surface finish follow common injection moulding guidance. Colour, material and finish as a design discipline: Del Curto and others, Politecnico di Milano. Platform and reuse after Baldwin and Clark, Design Rules (2000). EU repair rules: Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (EU) 2024/1781. Cost of delay after Reinertsen, The Principles of Product Development Flow (2009).

There is a second reason the argument is hard to settle. In 1987 Peter Gorb and Angela Dumas described what they called silent design: a large part of what a product becomes is decided by people who are not called designers. Where the screws sit, how thick a wall is, how a carton is sized. These are design decisions, taken in other budgets.

Consultancies have a name for weighing both sides. McKinsey calls it design to value and makes a point that matters here: unlike design to cost, it can end with a product that costs more to build, when buyers pay for the difference. Its roots go back to value analysis at General Electric in the 1940s, where Lawrence Miles defined value as function divided by cost. What follows is the small version, with no programme and a single decision.

Not every line is as easy to count. Unit cost and tooling come with a quote. Perceived quality, brand recognition and the fit with what customers need show up later, often in other products, and can only be surveyed or estimated. Marketing has the textbook tools for that half. David Aaker splits brand equity into awareness, perceived quality, associations and loyalty, and Jenni Romaniuk measures a brand’s distinctive assets by how many buyers link them to the brand, and to no other (Exhibit 2).

Exhibit 2

The lines that are easy to count are not the ones that build a brand.

Design effects sorted by two questions. Does the effect show in this product’s profit and loss, or later and elsewhere? Can it be counted, or only surveyed and estimated?

Every design effect, by two questions

Blue direct, shows in this productViolet indirect, shows later or elsewhere
Dashed edge hard to measure: surveyed or estimated

What it means. Put the top row on the one-page bill. Track the bottom row over years, with the same survey each time, and keep a share of the budget for it. A bill that leaves out the bottom row will always favour the cheaper design.

Sources and method

My own model. Brand equity as awareness, perceived quality, associations and loyalty: Aaker, Managing Brand Equity (1991) and Measuring Brand Equity Across Products and Markets, California Management Review (1996). Fame and uniqueness of distinctive assets: Romaniuk, Building Distinctive Brand Assets (2018). Perceived quality ranking: Stylidis and others, Chalmers University of Technology (2020). Needs as must-be and attractive quality: Kano and others (1984). Design in the balanced scorecard: Borja de Mozota, Design Management Review (2006).

A board, a pallet and a bill

On one hardware project the question was whether the circuit board should stay one large board or be split into two levels. One board was cheaper to make and to assemble. Two levels cost more, and they changed the housing: deeper, with a clearly smaller footprint. The cost view said one board. I cannot share the figures, so the exhibits here use invented values to show direction and proportion.

The footprint turned out to be the interesting number. I wrote a small sorting script in Rhino that takes the outer dimensions of a product and returns how many units fit on a Euro pallet. With the smaller footprint the count rose substantially. Sourcing and logistics then priced what that meant for freight, packaging and CO₂ per unit (Exhibit 3).

Exhibit 3

A dearer board can make a cheaper product.

One decision: split the circuit board into two levels, so the housing gets a smaller footprint. Each row is one line of the bill. Bars to the left cost more per unit, bars to the right save. Lengths are relative and show no amounts.

One decision, every line it touches Illustrative

Pink bar this line costs more per unitBlue bar this line saves per unit
Black bar the sum of the five linesPale bar counted separately

What it means. Seen from the electronics budget alone, the split loses. Across all lines it wins, and the surplus is a budget that can go into something the buyer notices.

Sources and method

Illustrative. The decision comes from a hardware project I worked on. Its amounts are confidential, so the bar lengths are invented to show direction and proportion, not measured data. CO₂ follows freight and is counted separately, for example with ISO 14083.

The saving in transport was larger than the extra cost of the second board. The decision that lost on the electronics line won on the bill, and it left a surplus. Exhibit 4 shows the mechanism with example cartons: a wide, flat box wastes part of the pallet, and a smaller, deeper one fills it.

Exhibit 4

The same pallet carries half as many again.

A Euro pallet seen from above and from its right-hand side, the 800 mm edge. Both views are drawn to the same scale and loaded to the same height. Both cartons hold the same volume. The wide, flat one fits two by two and leaves strips of the deck unused. The narrower, taller one fits three by three.

One Euro pallet, two carton sizes Illustrative

Grey cartons beforeBlue cartons after
Dashed line the loading height allowedBlack bar the palletHatched deck left unused

What it means. Units per pallet is a number design can move. It belongs in the brief as a target next to cost and size, and once it is there it works for every product in the range.

Sources and method

Illustrative carton sizes, not those of the project. Euro pallet of 1,200 by 800 mm and 144 mm high, loaded to 1,800 mm, which keeps the unit within the 1,950 mm upper loading height used in German retail logistics (CCG II, GS1 Germany). Simple grid loading without mixed orientations; weight limits are not considered.

Two things came out of it beyond the one product. Units per pallet became a target in the brief, a number that had not been there before. And because it is a rule about footprint and packaging, it applies to the next product in the range as well. This is where the single page meets the portfolio view the consultancies describe.

Spend the surplus where people notice

A surplus is only worth something if it goes to the right place. Research on perceived quality, much of it from Chalmers University of Technology with Volvo Cars, breaks the impression of quality into separate attributes and ranks them against effort and cost. The idea carries over to any product: list the elements that signal quality, estimate what each one adds and what it costs, and sort (Exhibit 5).

Exhibit 5

The strongest signals of quality are not the dearest ones.

Six places where a product can signal quality, sorted by effect per unit of added cost. For each, the first bar is the effect on how the product is judged and the second is what it adds to the cost of one unit.

Six elements, weighed against their cost Illustrative

Blue bar effect on how the product is judgedPink bar added cost per unit

What it means. Alignment comes first because it costs close to nothing when engineers know about it early. The budget found elsewhere then goes into one element people see or touch every day, and user research decides which.

Sources and method

Illustrative weights, not measured data. A method for ranking perceived quality attributes against effort, time and cost: Stylidis, Wickman and Söderberg, Chalmers University of Technology and Volvo Cars (2020).

Some of the strongest signals are nearly free. Screws that are centred, mirrored and evenly spaced make a housing look considered, and they cost nothing extra if the engineers know early that it matters. A short talk in each department about what the design is trying to do has paid back many times in my experience. Other signals cost real money: a light, the feel of a control, a surface. On one product the choice fell on the status light, backed by user research and by the company’s aim to be known for quality, and the number of LEDs was doubled. The pallet paid for the light.

For designers, and for external ones most of all, this changes the job. Ask how the costs are built, who decides and where there is room. When the bill is open, the cost side can say: this is the budget, put it where it does most. Product management then tests the choice with users.

Protect the detail

Value also has to last through the production run. Fine details in injection-moulded parts, such as a sharp chamfer or a surface texture, wear in the tool over time. How fast depends on the steel, the plastic and its fillers. The usual answers are to rework the cavity or to accept a softer edge. We made the fine element a replaceable insert instead. It is a small part of the tool, and each swap returns the moulded part to the designed state (Exhibit 6).

Exhibit 6

A small insert keeps a fine edge as designed for the whole run.

Sharpness of a fine moulded detail over the life of an injection mould. Without an insert the detail wears until it falls below the acceptance limit. With a replaceable insert it returns to the designed state at each swap.

One fine detail over the life of a mould Illustrative

Grey line without an insertViolet line with a replaceable insert
Dotted line the insert is swappedTinted area below the acceptance limit

What it means. The insert is a small, early expense on the tooling line. It buys constant quality over the run and avoids a stop for rework later, which is where the larger cost sits.

Sources and method

Schematic, not measured data. How fast a mould wears depends on the steel, its coating, the plastic and its fillers. Glass fibre in particular abrades cavities: comparative study of mould coatings in Coatings (2017).

On the bill this is an entry under risk and time: a small early expense against a later stop in production, and against a slow loss of quality that nobody signs off and everybody ships.

Software reads the same bill, later

In software the lines are the same and the timing differs. Hardware freezes a decision with the tool, so the page has to be written before. Software can measure afterwards. Ron Kohavi and Stefan Thomke describe a change to how Bing displayed ad headlines that raised revenue by 12 per cent, found through a controlled experiment. A study by Deloitte for Google across 37 brands linked a gain of 0.1 seconds in mobile load time to 8.4 per cent more retail conversions. Investment in architecture, in a fast front end or in careful motion can be argued the same way: name the line, then test.

What the evidence supports

The well-known numbers for the value of design are weaker than their reputation (Exhibit 7). McKinsey’s 2018 study of 300 companies found that those with the highest design scores grew revenue and shareholder returns far faster than their industries, and it says clearly that this is correlation. The Design Value Index chose its companies with hindsight. The often-quoted rule that 70 or 80 per cent of cost is fixed in design goes back to an informal survey, as Karl Ulrich and Scott Pearson found when they traced it in 1993.

Exhibit 7

The stronger the evidence for design, the narrower the claim it supports.

Seven kinds of evidence that design pays, from strongest to weakest. The dots are my reading of how well each one separates cause from coincidence.

Evidence that design pays, by strength

What it means. The broad claims rest on correlation and self-report. Cause has only been shown for single changes. That is a good reason to price one decision at a time.

Sources and method

Figures as published by the sources named in each row; links are in the list at the end of the article. The rating in dots is my own judgement, not a measurement.

I read this as support for the small version. Cause can be shown for single decisions, so that is where the case for design is strongest.

Limits

Not everything fits on the page. Brand effects build slowly and across products, and a company that only funds what can be priced in advance will stop making the things that later define it. Keep a share of the budget for work without a bill.

Design also costs. Marina Candi found that firms which use design openly attracted more new customers and were less profitable than firms where design stayed silent. Ulrich and Pearson saw no clear link between the quality of industrial design and manufacturing cost, in either direction.

The page itself can be gamed, because whoever writes it chooses the lines. It should be written together, with purchasing and logistics in the room.

What would prove me wrong

If teams that write such a page make the same decisions as teams that do not, it is paperwork. The same holds if the savings found on one line are routinely taken as margin and never reach the product.

A note on the numbers: figures from projects are withheld for confidentiality. Exhibits 3 to 6 use invented values and say so.

Sources (25)
Weighing value and cost
McKinsey, Capturing the full potential of design to valueMcKinsey, Design to value at scaleLawrence D. Miles and value analysisStylidis, Wickman and Söderberg, Perceived quality of products (2020)
Silent design
Shams and Lam on Gorb and Dumas, Silent design (1987)Candi, The sound of silence, Design Studies
Cost folklore
Ulrich and Pearson, Does product design really determine 80% of manufacturing cost? (1993)Barton, Love and Taylor, Design determines 70% of cost? (2001)
Brand and hard-to-measure value
Aaker, Measuring brand equity across products and markets, California Management Review (1996)Romaniuk, Building Distinctive Brand Assets (2018)Borja de Mozota, The four powers of design, Design Management Review (2006)Kano model
Design and performance
McKinsey, The business value of design (2018)Fortune on the Design Value Index (2017)Hertenstein, Platt and Veryzer (2005), summaryGemser and Leenders (2001)Forrester for IBM, Total Economic Impact (2018)Oxford Economics for DesignSingapore (2025)Yale Paprika, The Value of Design (2019)
Logistics and tooling
Design for logisticsDowlatshahi, The role of logistics in concurrent engineering (1996)Mould wear with glass fibre, Coatings (2017)Rhino
Software
Kohavi and Thomke, The Surprising Power of Online Experiments, HBR (2017)Milliseconds make millions, Deloitte for Google (2020)
Growth rings in a cut tree trunk, one ring for each year
Rows of tea bushes following the curve of a hillside

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.